Published:2024-09-19 17:16:06Source:JuxiaAuthor:Juxia
The practice of reloading a save to alter an unwanted outcome, commonly known as save scumming, continues to spark debate in the gaming community. Some players argue that save scumming undermines the integrity of the game, while others appreciate the opportunity to refine their approach until they achieve their desired results.
Josh Sawyer, the director behind Fallout: New Vegas, Pentiment, and Pillars of Eternity, recently voiced his critical stance on the matter. On social media, Sawyer remarked, "Manual save games were a mistake. They are the chicken nuggets of gaming: they bring you comfort but are bad for you and poison your gaming spirit."
The evolution of saving mechanics in video games has been diverse. While the era of requiring players to complete a game in a single session is long gone, modern games feature a variety of saving systems. These include manual saves with regular autosaves, checkpoint systems, and games that restrict saving to specific checkpoints.
Sawyer seems to advocate for a system where manual saving is not an option, and autosaves occur only after significant events. This approach locks in the decisions made up to that point, which is not typical of Fallout: New Vegas or Pillars of Eternity, but is a characteristic of Pentiment.
Raphael Colantonio, director of Dishonored, Weird West, and an upcoming untitled project, shared his perspective as well. Colantonio acknowledged Sawyer’s view but emphasized player choice, stating, "I don't disagree, but I let the gamers decide how they want to play; some just can't play without it." He mentioned that while he initially wanted to eliminate manual saving in Weird West to ensure players took ownership of their choices, this feature was ultimately included based on playtest feedback.
This ongoing debate highlights the tension between preserving the challenge and authenticity of gameplay versus accommodating player preferences for flexibility. Personally, while I find it challenging to achieve the "never detected" achievement in Dishonored without save scumming, I believe that for narrative-driven games where every choice matters, restricting manual saves might be a more fitting approach.
Marvel Tōkon: Fighting Souls – A New 4v4 Anime-Style Fighting Game from the Developers of Guilty Gea
Black Myth: Wukong Xbox Series X|S Release Date Confirmed for August 20, 2025 — Plus 20% Off Sale Ac
The Witcher IV: Ciri Leads, Unreal Engine 5.6 Powers a 60FPS Open-World Masterpiece
Genshin Impact Skirk Guide (5.7): Release Date, Ascension Materials, Best Weapons & Team Builds
Genshin Impact 5.7 Special Preview: Skirk & Traveler’s Chapter Reveal on June 6, 2025
BAKUDO: The Ultimate Ball Combat Sport – A Battle of Belief and Determination
NIKKE x Stellar Blade Special Livestream Scheduled for June 7, 2025
Persona 5: The Phantom X Launches Globally on June 26, 2025
Camp Hill Range Full Walkthrough & Gameplay Guide | Tips, Secrets & Strategy
Crave Saga X Characters and Weapon Tier List 2025
Waifu Slut School iOS
| Casual
Waifu Slut School Android
| Casual
Waifu Slut School Mod
| Casual
My Naughty Neighbor Game
| Casual
雀愿
| Puzzle
Spades Classic Card Game Online
| Card
Spades Classic Card Game iOS
| Card
Spades Classic Card Game Mod
| Card
Genshin Impact 5.7 Special Preview: Skirk & Traveler’s Chapter Reveal on June 6, 2025
BAKUDO: The Ultimate Ball Combat Sport – A Battle of Belief and Determination
NIKKE x Stellar Blade Special Livestream Scheduled for June 7, 2025
Persona 5: The Phantom X Launches Globally on June 26, 2025
Kamihime Project Tier List 2025: Top Characters & Best Teams
Coin Dozer: 10 Tips Every Beginner Should Know
How to Play Blackjack: 10 Steps from Beginner to Pro
Texas Hold’em: Learn the Rules, Hands, and Strategy in 10 Minutes
Texas Hold’em for Beginners: How to Play and Win
LIVE A HERO
Retro Hero Mr Kim
Empire of Passion
Arcane Quest Legends
Magic Snap: Momotaro
AllStar Manga Heroes
Lunescape
ONE PIECE Thousand Storm JP
Tap Titans 2