Red Dead Redemption 3 Must Address a Long-Standing Fan Theory

Red Dead Redemption 2 is renowned for its rich tapestry of mysteries. Rockstar Games has a reputation for embedding hidden gems in its narratives, and this sequel adds further intrigue to a long-standing theory within the franchise. Although there are currently three titles in the series, the original game, Red Dead Revolver, has sparked one of the most significant unresolved mysteries in Rockstar's history.

Launched in 2004, Red Dead Revolver marked Rockstar's entry into the Old West. While this title isn't directly considered canon to Red Dead Redemption and its 2018 prequel, the latter provides compelling evidence that all three games are deeply interconnected.

One intriguing character from Red Dead Revolver, Red Harlow, has not made a return in the Red Dead universe—at least, not in a way players can definitively recognize. A popular theory among fans suggests that Uncle, a senior member of Dutch's gang, could actually be an older version of Red Harlow. Many hope that Red Dead Redemption 3 will finally provide clarity on this theory.

The Case for Red Harlow as Uncle

There is substantial evidence supporting the theory that Red Harlow is indeed Uncle. The most compelling argument lies in their timelines, which align seamlessly. At the time of Red Dead Redemption 2, Uncle is approximately 50 years old, while Red Harlow is estimated to be around 30 during the events of Red Dead Revolver.

Since Red Dead Redemption 2 occurs about 20 years after Red Dead Revolver, the ages of Red and Uncle correspond perfectly. Furthermore, Uncle’s reflections on his past bear striking similarities to Harlow’s life. Both characters experienced the loss of their parents at a young age and survived as orphans, leading many fans to believe they are one and the same.

Currently, the direction of Red Dead Redemption 3 remains uncertain. Speculation suggests it could center on characters like Sadie Adler or Charles Smith, or perhaps revisit the past once more. Given that Red Dead Revolver launched the franchise, a return to Red Harlow’s story could provide much-needed answers regarding his fate.

An alternative theory posits that Red Harlow is simply a fictional legend within the Red Dead Redemption universe, making his story even more enigmatic.

Bringing the Franchise Full Circle

Although the canonicity of Red Dead Revolver is debated, a sequel could serve as the perfect opportunity to connect the entire franchise. The timeline of the Red Dead series spans several decades, with a significant 20-year gap between the events of Red Dead Revolver and Red Dead Redemption 2—a gap ripe for exploration.

Moreover, the Wild West was a brief historical period, making it essential to utilize the limited time available to tell epic stories. Exploring the years between Red Dead Revolver and Red Dead Redemption 2 presents an untapped narrative opportunity. The theory linking Red Harlow to Uncle is robust, and delivering a definitive answer in Red Dead Redemption 3 would undoubtedly be a groundbreaking revelation for fans.